|
|
|
|
Investment Planning Newsletter |
Bruce
Mullen
SMH Asset Management
August 16, 2006
Understanding the Alphabet Soup of Retirement Plans - Part II
In this second
article, I’ll focus on the employer / employee side of tax qualified
and tax advantaged retirement plans. A key component often missing
in retirement preparation is understanding the savings tools available,
and how they work for you. Many confusing acronyms as well as multiple
number designations exist in employer sponsored plans, most of which
are Federal tax driven; SEP IRA, SIMPLE, 401(k), Roth 401(k), Solo
401(k), 403(b), 457, etc. These designations are all short abbreviations
for parts of the tax code. The bottom line of each of these Federal
tax programs, similar to individual taxpayer programs, is that the
Government wants you to save toward your retirement, to supplement
your Social Security, and uses tax favored savings plans as an incentive.
These Federal
tax advantaged plans must generally treat all employees similarly
and stipulate maximum funding guidelines. They are similar to and
in a number of cases driven off the individual taxpayer IRA; Individual
Retirement Account. There are two major classes of these qualified
employer retirement plans, Defined Benefit and Defined Contribution.
Defined Benefit
(DB) plans are paid for fully by the employer, with the benefit
formula being fixed or “defined”. Examples of DB plans are traditional
pensions and SEPs. In these type pension plans, the employer usually
makes all the contributions based on a formula which must be consistent
for all employees. The employee usually makes no contribution.
Traditional
pensions typically base their benefit formula on each employee’s
service years, age, and compensation. These plans have been historically
utilized by large companies with consistent cash-flow and a stable
work force. However, because the plans are typically expensive and
difficult to maintain due to the detailed employee records and substantial
administration involved in governmental reporting requirements,
they have become less popular. Additionally, the employer carries
all the investment risk.
Simplified Employee
Pension (SEPs) are the small employer’s easy answer to a company
paid retirement plan. Typically the employer makes contributions
to a SEP IRA, established for each employee. A common formula would
pay 2-3% of an employee’s contribution into the employee’s SEP IRA.
The law allows funding up to 25% of total compensation for all employees,
up to a maximum of $43,000 per individual for 2006. Additional detailed
rules exist, so be sure to check with an advisor for your specific
situation. Benefits of a SEP for a small employer include; ease
of establishment, portability of benefits for employees, investment
risk borne by employee, and some flexibility in funding during a
poor year. Disadvantages are; it can be expensive to include part
time employees, the owner is tied to the same funding formula, and
it is usually inadequate as a sole retirement vehicle.
Defined Contribution
(DC) plans are the other major tax qualified retirement plan sponsored
by the employer. In this type plan, the employee’s input triggers
the employer’s contribution, whose funding level is defined by the
type of plan. These plans are popular with employees because the
employee controls funding and investment decisions, and get regular
statements thus better appreciating the employer match. The plans
are popular with employers as they are typically only obligated
to fund an account if the employee makes the financial commitment.
There are three primary DC plan types; SIMPLE, 401(k), and 403(b).
SIMPLE IRA plans,
or Savings Incentive Match Plan for Employees, are designed to use
either employee salary reduction contributions, which are matched
by the employer, or non-elective contributions by the employer alone.
The employer contribution is either a dollar for dollar match on
the first 3% of compensation that the individual elects to defer,
or a 2% of compensation nonelective contribution for all eligible
employees. Contributions are made into an employee’s SIMPLE IRA.
All employees, including part time who earn over $5,000, must be
included. The maximum an employee may defer for 2006 is $10,000,
plus an additional $2,500 catch up if they are age 50 plus. Other
rules apply so check with your advisor. Advantages to a SIMPLE plan
are; ease of administration, limited employer obligation until the
employee contributes, employee borne investment risk, and for self
employed individuals, a higher tax deductible amount than an IRA.
Disadvantages include; all employees over $5,000 must be included,
the owner is tied to the same funding as other employees, and, most
importantly, the $10,000 contribution limit is lower than other
employer plans.
401(k) plans,
which pertain to a section of the federal tax code, are very popular
for all sizes of employers due to the shortcomings of the plans
described above. A 401(k) is funded by employee payroll deferrals
and usually matched at some level by the employer. The employee
elects to have a portion of regular wages deferred into a third
party trustee account. Employee limits for 2006 are $15,000 plus
an additional $5,000 catch up for aged 50 plus participants. The
employer may elect to contribute a matching portion, typically 2-6%
of compensation. These plans can be set up to exclude part time
and short term employees. The plan can allow for loans to employees
of their holdings without forfeiture penalties, a provision many
employees appreciate.
There are several
401(k) plans that coincide with the different types of employers.
The traditional 401(k) plan is geared toward larger employers, as
the plan is more expensive to implement and administer. These plans
allow for the employer to withhold matches in poor years and can
be configured to benefit higher compensated employees. In 2006,
a Roth 401(k) was introduced offering the same provisions as a traditional
401(k), but funded with after-tax employee dollars and not taxed
upon withdrawal.
A Safe Harbor
401(k) eliminates much of the annual reporting of the traditional
401(k) and is less expensive to implement. For many small business
owners, it is the most popular retirement plan. However, it requires
a minimum employer match each year of between 2 – 3% of employee
compensation.
A Solo 401(k)
is especially designed for self proprietor businesses and husband
and wife companies. It can work well for contractors and realtors.
Similar funding levels of the $15,000 plus $5,000 catch up for the
employee plus the employer match make it one of the best tax-advantaged
saving plans available. Loan provisions can also be incorporated.
Two other plans
are available for non-profit and governmental organizations. The
403(b) plan is similar to the 401(k), but is designed for tax-exempt
and public schools, and a 457 plan is designed specifically for
government and non-church control organizations that are tax-exempt.
Most provisions, including employer contributions and employee deferrals,
are similar to the 401(k) with some existing differences.
The most important
consideration for any of these plans is to save to your maximum!
|
|